How to store Beans

I have vast numbers of coffee review notes on this site, all recent. Feel free to peruse them, to figure out where I'm coming from. I'm not prepared to go "15 rounds" on details with you, unless I'm sure you've got pretty good taste buds.
Your answer to "you haven't addressed the evidence I posted" is that you won't address it unless I first prove my taste buds are good enough?

I'm sure your many coffee reviews show that you have plenty of experience tasting coffee. But I shouldn't have to go through "vast numbers" of your reviews to figure out what evidence supports the storage claim you made here. If there's something in them that's relevant to this question, post it.

This was never particularly about my palate. You made a general claim that this storage method is going to cause problems. I posted evidence that at least calls that certainty into question, and you still haven't really addressed it.

If you don't want to keep going, that's fine. But requiring me to qualify as a taster, or sending me off to read your review history, still isn't an answer to the evidence I posted.
 
Your answer to "you haven't addressed the evidence I posted" is that you won't address it unless I first prove my taste buds are good enough?
Yes. It actually takes quite a lot of time and effort, to get to the level of proof you want out of things. Reading papers, watching videos, finding other people's results. If you are at the level where you know what you're talking about, as far as how things taste, it may be worth it. But if you can't tell, there's no point. That's just busywork for me, and I don't care about winning a debate with you. I care about what gets more people to brew good coffee.

Basic calibration: what's the last coffee you brewed, and how did you brew it?
 
Yes. It actually takes quite a lot of time and effort, to get to the level of proof you want out of things. Reading papers, watching videos, finding other people's results. If you are at the level where you know what you're talking about, as far as how things taste, it may be worth it. But if you can't tell, there's no point. That's just busywork for me, and I don't care about winning a debate with you. I care about what gets more people to brew good coffee.

Basic calibration: what's the last coffee you brewed, and how did you brew it?
This is getting more pretentious with every post.

First you weren't prepared to go "15 rounds" unless you were sure I had "pretty good taste buds." Now it's "Basic calibration:" and I have to tell you what coffee I brewed and how I brewed it before you decide whether I'm worth the effort of answering. That's some seriously self-important gatekeeping.

And now you're talking about the "level of proof" I want, as though I demanded some exhaustive scientific case. I didn't. That's a straw man. I asked you for any evidence supporting the claim you made.

You're the one who brought up papers, videos and other people's results. If those are what your confidence is based on, pointing me to the relevant material is a whole lot easier than the massive research project you're pretending I asked for.

The "other people's results" part is especially funny considering you were willing to bring up some unidentified person whose frozen coffee was supposedly "garbage," even though you couldn't remember the details or even where you saw it. Apparently that counted without any "basic calibration."

You made a confident claim, then gave me the horse-to-water routine as though your word was the water. Now that I'm asking what the claim is actually based on, I apparently have to pass your coffee tests before you'll bother showing me.

If you really care about getting people to brew good coffee, support the advice you give them. Turning a simple request for evidence into a test of whether someone is worthy of your time is exactly the kind of self-important nonsense that's made this whole exchange so ridiculous.
 
This is getting more pretentious with every post.

You haven't said a word about what you brew, or what you like. Just a lot of "you want to win" stuff - at great length! - that is a waste of time.

If you want to give your coffee buying, freezing, brewing, and tasting results in another thread, that would be a productive use of time.

Or you could even do it right here. I'm not picky.
 
You haven't said a word about what you brew, or what you like. Just a lot of "you want to win" stuff - at great length! - that is a waste of time.

If you want to give your coffee buying, freezing, brewing, and tasting results in another thread, that would be a productive use of time.

Or you could even do it right here. I'm not picky.
You quoted my first sentence and ignored every substantive point after it, then dismissed the rest as a lot of "you want to win" stuff.

But everything I wrote was responding directly to things you brought up: the "level of proof" you invented for me, the papers, videos and other people's results you mentioned, your anecdote with no details or reference, and your "basic calibration" requirement. Calling my response too long doesn't answer any of that.

Now you want my "coffee buying, freezing, brewing, and tasting results." Why? I'm not asking you to diagnose my coffee or teach me how to brew it. I'm asking what supports the general storage claim you made.

At this point the pattern is pretty obvious. Every time I ask what supports the claim, the discussion shifts to whether my palate, coffee or brewing meets your standards. That's awfully convenient, because if you get to grade me first, you never actually have to get back to the evidence.

And that's what makes this so pretentious and self-important. You've somehow appointed yourself the person who gets to decide whether I'm qualified enough to deserve an answer to a claim you made. You haven't established any reason why that should be the standard here.

If you have support for the storage claim, post it. If you don't want to, that's fine. But interviewing me about my coffee habits still doesn't answer the question.
 
Now you want my "coffee buying, freezing, brewing, and tasting results." Why?
I told you point blank why, several of my short posts ago.

Door #1 is you don't really have the palate, or the brewing skill. Exposing coffee to moisture is fine for you; you won't be able to tell the difference.

My theory of mind allows for other possible doors #2 #3 #4. But your strong unwillingness to even discuss how you do coffee at all, strongly suggests #1. Don't want to admit you do automatic drip? Don't want to say you like Starbucks just fine? Don't want to talk about drowning it in milk and sugar? These are very basic things, to decide what you can tell about coffee. What is the problem?

I know you freeze your coffee, you open the bag every time, and you have an expert who says it's ok. I have experts who say it isn't. I have zero freezing experience, and piles of ruining coffee at room temperature experience. I can brew, and taste. Allowing more moisture than required, is foolish.

We could have a high level conversation about how to taste if coffee is going bad. It is pointless if you have little taste.
 
I told you point blank why, several of my short posts ago.

Door #1 is you don't really have the palate, or the brewing skill. Exposing coffee to moisture is fine for you; you won't be able to tell the difference.

My theory of mind allows for other possible doors #2 #3 #4. But your strong unwillingness to even discuss how you do coffee at all, strongly suggests #1. Don't want to admit you do automatic drip? Don't want to say you like Starbucks just fine? Don't want to talk about drowning it in milk and sugar? These are very basic things, to decide what you can tell about coffee. What is the problem?

I know you freeze your coffee, you open the bag every time, and you have an expert who says it's ok. I have experts who say it isn't. I have zero freezing experience, and piles of ruining coffee at room temperature experience. I can brew, and taste. Allowing more moisture than required, is foolish.

We could have a high level conversation about how to taste if coffee is going bad. It is pointless if you have little taste.
You say you told me "point blank" why, but you didn't tell me several posts ago that "Door #1" was that I don't really have the palate or brewing skill. That's new.

And when you ask, "What is the problem?" this is the problem: you made a general claim about coffee storage on a public forum, and when I asked what it was based on, you decided I first needed to prove my palate and brewing skill to your satisfaction. That's not how a normal discussion works. Either support the claim, explain what it's based on, or don't. Turning it into a qualification test for the person asking is bizarrely self-important.

It's also ironic that you've complained about how much I've written. You've now spent several posts explaining why I need to qualify for an answer, including the questions about automatic drip, Starbucks, milk and sugar. That has taken a lot more effort than simply pointing to whatever support you say exists. You're the one dragging this out.

And "Door #1" itself is something you pulled out of thin air. You've never tasted coffee I've brewed, watched me brew, or tested my palate. Refusing your "basic calibration" isn't evidence that I'd fail it. And even if I used automatic drip and drank Starbucks, that would only say something about whether I personally might notice the effect. It wouldn't tell us whether the storage method itself causes the effect you claimed.

Then there's the part I find especially odd: you now admit you have "zero freezing experience," yet you previously called letting the bag "completely air dry before using" the "proper method." Air-drying a cold bag means exposing it to room air, which is precisely where the condensation issue comes from. Where did this supposedly proper procedure come from?

You say you have experts who disagree with mine, and you've mentioned papers, videos and other results. Saying those things exist isn't evidence. What they actually say and what they're based on would be relevant. None of that becomes more or less valid depending on whether I pass your personal coffee test.

That's the issue. You turned a question about a coffee-storage claim into an examination of the person asking it.
 
You say you told me "point blank" why, but you didn't tell me several posts ago that "Door #1" was that I don't really have the palate or brewing skill. That's new.

Coulda sworn I did. Was talking about your taste buds too diplomatic or something?

I think you are a real person, but are you using a chatbot to write your posts? It would explain a few things.
 
Coulda sworn I did. Was talking about your taste buds too diplomatic or something?

I think you are a real person, but are you using a chatbot to write your posts? It would explain a few things.
You did talk about my taste buds earlier. What you hadn't said was that my refusal to take your "basic calibration" supposedly meant I lacked the palate or brewing skill. That's the part that was new.

Yes, I’m a real person, and no, the thoughts are going from my brain to my fingertips. But I do love how you still want to turn this discussion about me instead of what you actually wrote.

You called it the "proper method" to let a frozen bag "completely air dry before using." That means exposing the cold bag and beans to room air, while your whole argument is that exposing cold coffee to humid room air causes the condensation problem.

I asked where that "proper method" came from and how it makes sense. You skipped that completely.

And you actually used "air dry" twice in your first reply to me, in two different situations. In response to my method, you said to let the bag "completely air dry before using." Then for someone freezing a partly used bag while they're away, you said to take it out, "let the whole thing air dry," and then continue where they left off.

So explain those two instructions. What exactly are you telling someone to do in each case, and how does exposing cold coffee to room air until it "air dries" avoid the condensation problem you're warning about?
 
Or there’s an art to storing them the last beans I had was a good bag of Starbucks blonde I did like grinded up and syrupy it was and strong lighter blend though..but usually I’m a gevalia or cafe blend kinda person. French Roast is some good smokes or dipp coffee..I’m curtailing like what I’ve said to the last poster but I’m all ADHD type so smoke probaly healthy in someone like me and becoming motivated…I don’t believe what doctors say either hasn’t bothered me in the slightest.
 
So explain those two instructions.
I welcome any productive discourse you have to offer in other threads. I'm not shutting the door.

But in this thread, you've refused to reveal very simple things about your skill level and capabilities. Thus I see no point in explaining anything further to you. Either because of your unwillingness to understand, your inability to, or that I might say something too simple and just be talking down to you. You are determined to remain "a person of mystery" and that has consequences for communication.
 
Why bother reading into most of the crap posted online about theories, 'expert opinion' lmao on those so called experts, when all that matters is what you actually experience for yourself in your home with your equipment, etc. to cater to your preferences! Why argue trying to get a point across when it makes no real difference at the end of the day?

I started out with instant, then drip, then drip grinding my own 'burr' grinder that was far from awesome. Then to moka pot and finally quality espresso... various machines, grinders, burr types, running a full blown mobile commercial setup... Tried all sorts of buying/storage methods along the way and gladly vouch for vacuum packing/deep freezing as I did that for quite awhile until I jumped into home roasting. THAT is the single best improvement I've made with coffee as nothing gives you the absolute most control/consistency as doing your own roasting and no longer stuck with the crap currently flooding the market at ridiculous prices.

The approach I take gives me outstanding roast quality/consistency that gives superb espresso for my taste that no place away from home has ever came remotely close to matching. At the end of my day that's all that will ever matter and I will never have the FOMOR that currently plagues society.
 
I welcome any productive discourse you have to offer in other threads. I'm not shutting the door.

But in this thread, you've refused to reveal very simple things about your skill level and capabilities. Thus I see no point in explaining anything further to you. Either because of your unwillingness to understand, your inability to, or that I might say something too simple and just be talking down to you. You are determined to remain "a person of mystery" and that has consequences for communication.
Understand what exactly? People tend to get this mindset that there are certain guidelines that we should follow or we just have it all wrong, lmao. I gladly call anyone out on that as 'almost' every aspect in life is opinion based and not much else. Of course there are some things that are objective that most can agree on, but it's totally fine to think outside the box. Personally I always go against the grain just to get a point across that I can equal or exceed any other method ever attempted for a given task.
 
I agree that firsthand experience trumps all secondhand advice. I can do freezing trials, but I'm still in the middle of carbon dioxide trials.

Why prove anything to others about coffee? Because if we never proved anything about coffee, people wouldn't even know how to grind their own beans and so forth. They'd be helpless, and often drinking inferior coffee. The world can do better than that, so some of us prove things about coffee.

But, knowing what's worth the effort and what isn't, that takes experience. There are lots of ways to get lost in the weeds.

until I jumped into home roasting. THAT is the single best improvement I've made with coffee as nothing gives you the absolute most control/consistency as doing your own roasting and no longer stuck with the crap currently flooding the market at ridiculous prices.

I am intrigued by that, and will be asking some questions in another thread. If someone comes up with a basically better strategy, tactics may not matter anymore.
 
I agree that firsthand experience trumps all secondhand advice. I can do freezing trials, but I'm still in the middle of carbon dioxide trials.

Why prove anything to others about coffee? Because if we never proved anything about coffee, people wouldn't even know how to grind their own beans and so forth. They'd be helpless, and often drinking inferior coffee. The world can do better than that, so some of us prove things about coffee.

But, knowing what's worth the effort and what isn't, that takes experience. There are lots of ways to get lost in the weeds.



I am intrigued by that, and will be asking some questions in another thread. If someone comes up with a basically better strategy, tactics may not matter anymore.
Thing is taste/expectations will always be subjective... as in what might be inferior to you will be top notch to others. Who's to say they're misguided, wrong, etc.? I know many that are just fine with instant, 24/7 hot plate sludge at Waffle House, Dunkin Donuts K-cups, etc. If someone makes the effort to ask how I do things then sure I'll explain how things work for me, whether they can make use of it or not isn't my concern.

Will also say if you took the time/effort to get into home roasting you would never have to bother with long term storage experimentation as you can do what you want as needed, age/rotate batches to max out right when you need it, etc. Doesn't have to be costly either... I found a fantastic old school popper at a Goodwill yrs ago for $3, factor in quality green for say $6-8/lb and have at it. Sweet Maria's offers their version of a modified popper at a really good price. Actually saw one on Marketplace awhile back in my area really affordable and just 4 batches ran through it. Of course it's not easy by any means to get quality batches consistently, but will honestly say the only batches I was never satisfied with was the first 2 that I did. Since then I've done several thousand batches and no complaints at all.
 
Back
Top Bottom