- Jun 25, 2026
- 238
- 16
Thing is taste/expectations will always be subjective... as in what might be inferior to you will be top notch to others.
Given that connoisseurs have established at least one standardized lexicon of tasting terms, I say that is impossible. Damage to coffee is objective. There are people who can taste it just fine, and there are people who drown their coffee in other flavors, so they taste nothing. There are also people who are smokers, or otherwise have their taste buds ruined for various reasons, such as COVID recovery. There are people who could taste things, but much like consuming excess salt, they're so addicted to caffeine that the bitterness of their strong brews is going to dominate.
The lexicon is for people who actually know coffee. Yes opinions on quality and scoring will vary, but not remotely by as much as you claim. It is not I see black, you see white, I see day, you see night. It is I have basic competence in tasting, and someone else does not.
Advanced tasting, sure, plenty of variations in what people like. But let's make sure everyone gets basics right and not invent "culturally relative" excuses for it.
That said, I know nothing of Greek / Turkish "mud" coffee. Probably everything I think, goes out the window for them. I'm not prepared to discuss Italian espresso "third wave" either, as I'm espresso ignorant. Those things would kill me!
A basically competent person should be able to make an ok pourover using ok beans. They should be able to taste why it is ok and why it isn't. And they should be drinking it black, no adulterations or masks. They should understand coffee to water ratios. All very simple stuff that all internet experts and world champion brewers, agree upon. No excuses for not knowing basics. Not the subtle picky stuff, "precise recipes" and techniques, not talking about that.
You get basically competent baristas at retail all the time, if you ask them for a pourover. It is skill, not excuses. They can't sell the product if they don't have the skill.







