carbon dioxide generation for bean storage

I never got anything good out of those Sea Turtle Blend beans. I did manage to demonstrate a preservation effect though. A 3 day difference in bean age was preserved, rather than all jars simply failing equally after nearly 2 months.

It's going to take a more methodical go at it, to prove anything. Most importantly, I need to start from "known good" coffee, that I already know how it's supposed to taste when brewed properly. Not something I am disliking straight out of the bag.

I forgot that I did a "nothing but CO2" control jar, dated July 14, 2026. Today is 17+31+30+3 = 81 days later. Opening the Mason jar carefully so as not to disturb the contents, and striking a match, it snuffed immediately when put below the rim. CO2 itself, stores just fine.
 
I'm scaling up the size of the Mason jar. This one I think is 32 fl. oz.

I have a new gizmo for loading coffee beans into a Mason jar full of carbon dioxide. It's made from half a peanut jar and a big funnel. The idea is to minimize the loss of carbon dioxide when adding the beans.

IMG_3391.webp


The plastic jar has a curved pinch in it. If it's cut at the right point, that pinch will exactly fit the mouth of the jar, firmly snug in place.

I tried drilling with a 1/2" brad point, then a 5/8" spade bit, then finally a 3/4" spade bit to make the hole in the plastic lid. The plastic is crumbly and doesn't take a kitchen knife very well.

Eventually I realized that putting the lid on a piece of scrap wood, and pressing through with the spade into the wood, would make an acceptably neat hole. It sort of melts the plastic.

There are other ways to make holes that don't require power tools, but this way I got it done fairly quickly. A box cutter risks making a mistake.
 
1/2 cup household vinegar 5% acidity
4 tsp baking soda
small funnel
1500 mL wine bottle
32 fl. oz. Mason jar
plastic peanut jar extender with 3/4" hole in cap
big funnel for beans

I poured the vinegar into the wine bottle from a Pyrex measuring cup with a small spout on it, so that I would not have to get the small funnel wet. I put the small dry funnel into the mouth of the wine bottle. I added the baking soda 1 tsp at a time, waiting for the fizz to subside before adding another spoonful. There was unreacted baking soda at the bottom of the bottle, so I swirled the bottle to mix it in. Afterwards there is still some left because this is a vinegar limited reaction.

I removed the peanut jar extender lid. I decanted the CO2 from the wine bottle into the wide mouth of the extender, being careful not to tip any liquid into it. I did this for about 2 minutes, not really knowing how long it would take. During that time I felt a bit woozy, I think from the smell of CO2. Which means I did generate it, and hopefully enough made it into the Mason jar.

I carefully put the plastic lid back on the extender. I put the large bean funnel into the 3/4" hole. I opened the plastic coffee bag for the 1st time and while keeping it upright, carefully scooped beans from the plastic zipper, into the big funnel. I did not pour from the bag because any CO2 that might still be in the bag, I'm trying to keep it in there.

I put 16 fl. oz. of beans in the Mason jar so that it is half full. While doing so, I got that woozy feeling of inhaling CO2 again. That could be a good sign. The whole point of the contraption is to force O2 upwards as beans go downwards, while trying to minimize the loss of CO2.

I sealed the plastic zipper on the coffee bag. I carefully removed the plastic extender and carefully put the Mason jar lid on tight. I labeled this bottle "CO2 first, extender, 10-4-26".

I typed all of the above up as I was doing these operations. It took some time. I'm relying on CO2 being heavier than air, so that this shouldn't have to be a rush.

Now I'll be brewing the remaining coffee. It's not an equal split, there's much less left in the bag. I hope I will establish "known good" coffee from that. I'll wait weeks before opening the Mason jar.
 
That Mason jar I stored on Oct. 4, 2026 was the Cafe Fem Blend. I've now labeled it as such. Meanwhile I used up the bag. I got it dialed in and passable, but it was never super compelling. The blend is not consistent about providing the claimed apricot flavor. This bag had none of it, although it did have the effervescence that is like a placeholder for where the apricot should be. It is somewhat interesting so I wouldn't call it useless coffee, just not super compelling coffee. Thus I'm going to park that one for awhile and come back to it. Get something else going.

Now I've got Concepcion Huista from Cooperative Coffee Roasters in Asheville NC. It's a single origin from Huehuetenango, Guatemala. It was roasted on Sep. 28, 2026, a little over 3 weeks ago. I am opening the bag today. Using the same CO2 storage method as above, I've labeled another jar "Coop Huista, CO2 first, ext., 10-21-26".
 
I opened the Cafe Fem Blend jar today, 23 days later, a little over 3 weeks. When scooping beans I'm trying to disturb the CO2 as little as possible, to see if I can continue to get some preservative effect. Brewing was successful, there's definitely preservation. It does seem more bitter than when I put them in, but it's not overwhelming. It remains to be seen whether it's just a difference in my brewing technique, or a slight characteristic change in the coffee.
 
I'm tasting noticeable degradation of coffee due to moisture spoilage. I don't know whether moisture was a problem with the original CO2 storage, or if it has rapidly onset since the Mason jar was opened. I seriously doubt that latent CO2 is preventing moisture exchange in a large jar.
 
The growing woodiness of the coffee continues. I conclude that a big, wide mouthed Mason jar is very bad storage when opened multiple times a day. Way too much air exchange.

However the coffee only seems to suffer the absorption of moisture and the loss of volatile organic compounds. It doesn't seem to oxidize or have the oils go rancid. So the brews are clearly defective, yet drinkable because the original flavor components are still there. Not saying they're desirable, but it's not crazy to actually finish all of this ruined coffee, rather than throwing it out. It seems that some kinds of coffee staling are worse than others.

I have a possible answer for the problem. If the coffee is originally loaded into the Mason jar in small plastic zipper style bags, with the zipper mouths facing up, perhaps they can all be drowned in CO2. The jar can be sealed with the bags still open. When the jar is opened weeks or months later, then the bags can be closed.

Vertical, tube-like zipper bags would be better for this kind of packing, than the typical sandwich bag. Basically a single dosing container that's flexible rather than rigid. I'll look around whether such bags exist, what they're made out of, and what they cost.

Yes, tube-like plastic bags are readily obtainable on Amazon. I ordered 100 pcs 2"x5", 6 MIL thick LDPE food grade for $10. Someone else had 1"x5" but they were only 1.4 MIL thick. 5" is the right height for my current Mason jars. It leaves 1" of clearance at the top of the jar where the neck narrows. We shall see what it's like to pack with these bags in practice.
 
Last edited:
I opened the Coop Huista jar today. Judging by the weaker smell, I suspect that the loss of volatile organic compounds cannot be prevented.

I'm repacking it into 2"x5" plastic bags. I took 3 tblsp out to make some coffee. The rest I managed to pack into 7 of these little plastic bags. They have a tendency to close up sideways, especially if you shove too many of them into the jar. I hope these are open wide enough to receive the CO2. If not, then I could force them open with small metal rings.

IMG_3393.webp


Now using the plastic extender and funnel, I will add CO2 per the 1/2 cup vinegar, 4 tsp baking soda recipe above. Then seal.

Somehow that didn't seem like enough CO2. I didn't get that woozy headache feeling when the excess flows out everyhere. I added another 1/2 cup of vinegar and 3 more tsp of baking soda to the wine bottle and decanted a 2nd time. Basically that's doubling the CO2 recipe, since 7 tsp is the actual value for 1 cup of vinegar I established awhile ago. I definitely got the woozy feeling on the 2nd decanting.

A final question is how long does it take CO2 to displace O2 in those little plastic bags full of beans? Does it even happen, in any kind of reasonable time? I don't know. I could devise some kind of loading tubes for the bags, decant CO2 first, add beans, then remove the tubes. The tubes really only have to be long enough to keep the bags open, so they could be say 2" long plastic, of an appropriate diameter.
 
Last edited:
5 hours later it was time to make the evening coffee. I opened the jar and immediately sealed 6 of the 7 small plastic bags, trying not to disturb them from their positions. My hope was to trap any latent CO2 far more than any new or persisting O2.

The 7th bag I removed from the jar. It's slightly awkward to handle the things as they're a bit slippery and prone to falling over. While fiddling with it I knocked it over on the counter and spilled some beans. After that I put it upright in a container, rather than expecting it to stay put on its own.

The narrow shape means the only thing you're gonna do with it in the real world, is tip it sideways to dispense the beans. So O2 is gonna go in, there's no helping it. You'd drive yourself crazy trying to keep it upright to preserve whatever CO2 might be in there. I dispensed 3.5 tblsp of beans and still had some left in the bag. I put the bag back in the jar with the other bags and sealed it.

I doubt the coffee can be stored in perfect single doses, because the strength of the coffee is changing over time. Now if short tubes are used to hold the bags open, and the whole jar is flooded with CO2, and then the coffee is added afterwards, and the bags are closed after giving everything time to settle, maybe the coffee won't age as much. Maybe VOC stability is better in a small bag than a big jar. Still, I think VOCs are gonna release regardless. That will be my expectation until proven otherwise.
 
5 hours later it was time to make the evening coffee. I opened the jar and immediately sealed 6 of the 7 small plastic bags, trying not to disturb them from their positions. My hope was to trap any latent CO2 far more than any new or persisting O2.

The 7th bag I removed from the jar. It's slightly awkward to handle the things as they're a bit slippery and prone to falling over. While fiddling with it I knocked it over on the counter and spilled some beans. After that I put it upright in a container, rather than expecting it to stay put on its own.

The narrow shape means the only thing you're gonna do with it in the real world, is tip it sideways to dispense the beans. So O2 is gonna go in, there's no helping it. You'd drive yourself crazy trying to keep it upright to preserve whatever CO2 might be in there. I dispensed 3.5 tblsp of beans and still had some left in the bag. I put the bag back in the jar with the other bags and sealed it.

I doubt the coffee can be stored in perfect single doses, because the strength of the coffee is changing over time. Now if short tubes are used to hold the bags open, and the whole jar is flooded with CO2, and then the coffee is added afterwards, and the bags are closed after giving everything time to settle, maybe the coffee won't age as much. Maybe VOC stability is better in a small bag than a big jar. Still, I think VOCs are gonna release regardless. That will be my expectation until proven otherwise.
And you think home roasting would be too involved...
 
And you think home roasting would be too involved...
Proving a new method takes longer than following a well known method. Doesn't mean it's difficult once you know what you're doing.

Mixing the vinegar and baking soda is easy enough, but I find decanting CO2 from the wine bottle to be a bit tedious. I'd like a "better" dispensing method but I haven't thought of one yet. The wine bottle method works, and is simple to get the equipment for. That's what it has going for it.
 
Proving a new method takes longer than following a well known method. Doesn't mean it's difficult once you know what you're doing.

Mixing the vinegar and baking soda is easy enough, but I find decanting CO2 from the wine bottle to be a bit tedious. I'd like a "better" dispensing method but I haven't thought of one yet. The wine bottle method works, and is simple to get the equipment for. That's what it has going for it.
Why feel the need to 'prove' anything to be honest? I get the idea of doing something on the edge so to speak to see what it might offer, but it seems like you're OK with buying subpar coffee and trying desperately to make it palatable a bit longer than possible. Kind of like Illy for example... they go through an insane amount of steps from tree to those tins they sell coffee in, with nitrogen flushing I believe it is. Sure it is likely quite fresh/locked in for awhile, but as soon as that seal is disrupted O2 pours in and the contents might be good for a few days to a week at very most and nothing really can be done to offset that.
 
Why feel the need to 'prove' anything to be honest?
To solve problems that can be of benefit to humanity. CO2 storage seems overlooked, especially in home application.

Illy doesn't work in practice. Nitrogen displacement storage might work well for 6 months according to some papers or trade info that someone pulled sometime, some discussion I remember having. Illy charges a lot of money for their product compared to the US competition, and thus it sits on grocery store shelves a long time. 2 years is typical of what I've seen in Winston-Salem NC. That fancy storage method isn't any good after 6 months. It leads to YouTube videos of people opening up cans of Illy and getting completely foul rotten garbage. I don't know if the distribution economics of Illy are better in Europe, but they're terrible here.

I don't know of an easy way to generate nitrogen in the home, or in the garden. Whereas generating CO2 is trivial and cheap.

Sure it is likely quite fresh/locked in for awhile, but as soon as that seal is disrupted O2 pours in and the contents might be good for a few days to a week at very most and nothing really can be done to offset that.
That's the point of the 2"x5" plastic bags. They don't prove anything yet because the coffee was not stored with them originally. Next bag, we'll see if it works better. Especially if I figure out a way to fill the bags with CO2 first, before adding the beans.
 
To solve problems that can be of benefit to humanity. CO2 storage seems overlooked, especially in home application.

Illy doesn't work in practice. Nitrogen displacement storage might work well for 6 months according to some papers or trade info that someone pulled sometime, some discussion I remember having. Illy charges a lot of money for their product compared to the US competition, and thus it sits on grocery store shelves a long time. 2 years is typical of what I've seen in Winston-Salem NC. That fancy storage method isn't any good after 6 months. It leads to YouTube videos of people opening up cans of Illy and getting completely foul rotten garbage. I don't know if the distribution economics of Illy are better in Europe, but they're terrible here.

I don't know of an easy way to generate nitrogen in the home, or in the garden. Whereas generating CO2 is trivial and cheap.


That's the point of the 2"x5" plastic bags. They don't prove anything yet because the coffee was not stored with them originally. Next bag, we'll see if it works better. Especially if I figure out a way to fill the bags with CO2 first, before adding the beans.
I am improving humanity by recommending people become more self-sufficient and roast their own. Simply light yrs better than most roasted these days and save $ in the process. You would be mind blown with the neverending possibilities of doing your own blending, level of development to suit you instead of overpriced bagged WTF, etc.
 
Oh I mostly believe you, but there are some downsides, like the inhalation safety issues. You may also not appreciate that not everyone has sufficient control over their living situation, to be able to roast. Whereas I guarantee you, everyone's got enough control over their residence to mix vinegar and baking soda. It's kid safe science class stuff.

Your equipment, relatively expensive. Mine, probably $15 for Mason jars, $5 for vinegar and baking soda. Jury's out on plastic bags, might not be the final way.
 
Back
Top Bottom